| By Owen Matthews
and Rana Foroohar / Newsweek International
It is said that
after so many decades of trying to become Western, Istanbul glories
in the rediscovery of a very modern identity. European or not, it is
one of the coolest cities in the world.
Spend a summer night
strolling down Istanbul's Istiklal Caddesi, the pedestrian
thoroughfare in the city's old Christian quarter of Beyoglu, and
you'll hear something surprising. Amid the crowds of nocturnal
revelers, a young Uzbek-looking girl plays haunting songs from
Central Asia on an ancient Turkish flute called a saz. Nearby,
bluesy Greek rembetiko blares from a CD store. Downhill toward the
slums of Tarlabasi you hear the wild Balkan rhythms of a Gypsy
wedding, while at 360, an ultratrendy rooftop restaurant, the sound
is Sufi electronica—cutting-edge beats laced with dervish ritual.
And then there are the clubs—Mojo, say, or Babylon
—where the young and beautiful rise spontaneously from their tables
to link arms and perform a complicated Black Sea line dance, the
horon. The wonder is that each and every one of these styles is
absolutely native to the city, which for much of its history was the
capital of half the known world.
The sounds of
today's Istanbul convey something important. They're evidence of a
cultural revival that's helping the city reclaim its heritage as a
world-class crossroads. After decades of provincialism, decay and
economic depression—not to mention the dreary nationalism mandated
by a series of governments dominated by the military—Istanbul is
re-emerging as one of Europe's great metropolises. "Istanbul is
experiencing a rebirth of identity," says Fatih Akin,
director of this summer's award-winning film "The Sound of
Istanbul" an odyssey through the city's rich musical traditions.
Akin grew up in Germany but during the past decade has rediscovered
his Turkish roots. "There's such richness," he says. "So many people
have crossed Istanbul and left their culture here."
A renaissance in
the city
Signs of renewed self-confidence are everywhere. The city is still
thickly atmospheric, with bazaars, Byzantine churches and Ottoman
mansions pretty much everywhere. But that faded grandeur has
recently been leavened with new energy. Stock markets are surging.
Young, Western-educated Turks are returning home to start
businesses. Foreigners are snapping up choice real estate. Turkish
painters, writers, musicians, fashion designers and filmmakers are
increasingly in the international spotlight. Two major new private
museums devoted to Turkish art, the Istanbul Modern and the
Pera Museum, have opened in the past year alone. Private
galleries like GalerIst and Platform are showcasing,
and fostering, new artists from Turkey and around the region.
The city's
renaissance is part and parcel of Turkey's embrace of Europe. It's
no accident that the Modern's opening was pushed up last December to
coincide with the European Union's decision to begin accession talks
with Ankara. Turkey's drive to "join Europe" undergirds the economic
reforms that have given both Turks and foreigners the confidence to
invest and buoyed the country's prospects. Inflation is in the
single digits for the first time in 30 years, unemployment is down
and GDP growth is more than 9 percent. Reforms pushed by the EU—from
its insistence that the military step back from politics to
human-rights and free-speech liberalizations—have reshaped Turkey's
political and social landscape. At bottom, Istanbul's new look would
not have been not be possible had the country's government not been
so determined to prove its Western credentials.
In every area of
life, a new generation of young Turks is reaching outward. This
year's Art Biennale will draw artists from Bosnia, Iran, Egypt,
Greece and Lebanon—a most uncommon mix—while the Web Biennale will
feature work by Armenians, Ukrainians, Serbs, Macedonians and
Romanians. "Istanbul these days has as much dynamism as New York,"
says Genco Gulan, director of the Istanbul Contemporary
Art Museum . If anything, he enthuses, "Istanbul is more alive.
There's more interest here in doing something new."
Forcing the
borders
That cultural vibrancy has come hand in hand with a physical
renaissance, the likes of which Istanbul hasn't seen in a century.
Begin with Beyoglu, an area of grand 19th-century apartment
buildings reminiscent of Budapest or Vienna that was largely
abandoned by its Greek and Jewish inhabitants in the 1950s and
became a Kurdish and Gypsy slum. "Fifteen years ago, you'd be afraid
to go there," says Gulen Guler, a film producer who lives in
the neighborhood. Fusion restaurants, organic grocers and designer
candle shops now abound, along with the city's trendiest shops,
galleries, design studios and clubs—many of them standouts of
contemporary design. Beyoglu is also home to a growing colony of
young foreigners buying up cheap apartments. "This place is
attracting people away from very cool scenes elsewhere, like
Berlin," says Andrew Foxall , one of the owners of 20
Million, a design and photography studio in Cukurcuma, the artiest
of Beyoglu's enclaves.
The rise of Beyoglu
is a good metaphor —for Istanbul as a whole. At its best, it
showcases all that's original and vibrant in the city. At its worst,
it does just the opposite—testifying to Turkey's cultural
insecurities. Yes, the melting pot that is the Istiklal Caddesi is
genuine enough. But what to make of the Fransiz Sokak, a
whole street filled with faux French cafes and restaurants, complete
with baguettes and piped accordion music? Contrast that with the
restaurant Dilara's Abracadabra, whose owner, Dilara Erbay
, conjures up a truly innovative new food culture based on
traditional seasonal rhythms. "This is Anatolia, a very spiritual
and holy place," says Erbay. "Anatolian food is alive, all the old
stories are there. We prepare special foods when someone dies, when
they are born, when guests come. You can tell all your life in
food." Erbay's next big thing is Sufi cuisine, simple and pure food
eaten from a communal bowl "to symbolize love and oneness," rooted
in Turkey's ancient culture of Sufi Islamic mysticism.
It's a constant
tussle, this East-West divide. For years being cool and innovative
has long meant, simply, being Western. More and more Turkish artists
are rediscovering their own voices, grounded in their own traditions
rather than borrowed ones. Listen, for instance, to the weird,
haunting melodies of the dervish rituals that shape the mesmerizing
electronic music of Mercan Dede, who mixes Sufi classical
music played on the ney (a kind of flute) with computer beats. Look
at the upper floors of the Pera Museum, dedicated to the work of
young Turkish artists. (One female painter crowns her angry
self-portrait with a Byzantine-style gold halo; a digital
photomontage of horses and soldiers turns what might have been a
battle of classical Greece and Persia into something resembling a
videogame; in one photo of a large mosque, minarets tilt at 45
degrees, evoking missiles.) Or try on some of designer Gonul
Paksoy 's sumptuous Ottoman-inspired gowns made of antique silks
and rich embroidery. These are all signs of a cultural voice growing
from within, and no longer imported from abroad.
Not all the new art
is a celebration. Filmmaker Kutlug Ataman, shortlisted for
last year's prestigious British Turner Prize, cuts close to Turkey's
sociocultural bone. His latest video installation, "Kuba"
constructs a communal portrait of life in an Istanbul shantytown,
voice by voice. The subjects range from criminals, drug addicts and
teenage delinquents to religious radicals and the poor—an
uncomfortably real slice of daily life at the margins.
Bold artistic
voices like Ataman's are bound to collide with Turkey's many
taboos—nationalist versus European, modern versus traditional,
secular versus religious. While bright young things drink and flirt
in expensive Beyoglu restaurants, the more numerous poor look on in
bewilderment and not a little disapproval. Outside one trendy record
shop specializing in reggae and rap, graffiti on the wall reads RAP
NO—MUSLIM YES. And just a hundred meters from the lively bars of
Istiklal, an armored personnel carrier stands permanently parked
outside the police headquarters on Tarlabasi Boulevard, ready for
use during the sporadic disorders among Tarlabasi's largely Kurdish
minority.
Istanbul and its
artists are testing new political limits as well. Aynur, a Kurdish
singer featured in "The Sound of Istanbul" recalls that when
she started performing 10 years ago, police would pull the plug on
her. With new laws (another nod to the EU) authorizing broadcasts in
Kurdish, she can now sing wherever and whenever she wants. But, she
says, "I only wish these changes were happening because we really
believed in them, not because we're becoming members of the EU."
Even novelist Orhan Pamuk , whose books have been a huge
success in Turkey and the West, was pilloried by nationalists
earlier this year when he dared to ask what had happened to the
Armenians of the Ottoman Empire in 1915, when hundreds of thousands
were killed.
Still, taken
together, the changes have been dramatic. For decades now, Greeks
and Turks have lived in enmity. Yet the Pozitif photo gallery
in Galata is currently hosting a show of stark images from Imroz, a
Turkish Aegean island with a tiny, and dying, Greek population. It's
a sad exhibit, says photographer Murat Yaykin, but "it's
important to tell the story" of how Greeks and Turks not so long ago
lived side by side in harmony. A huge crowd also turned out last
month when Greek singer Aliki Kayaloglou performed poetry by
Greek poets Elytis, Kavafis and Sappho, as well
as Turkish poet Nazim Hikmet, set to music by contemporary
Greek composer Manos Hadjidakis . Greek contemporary pop
sells well in the record shops on Istiklal.
Perhaps most
encouraging is the fact that, as Istanbul goes, so goes much of the
rest of the country. The megalopolis accounts for roughly 45 percent
of national industry, 55 percent of GDP and 60 percent of the
country's exports. A whole generation of young Turks, educated
abroad, is now being drawn back to their homeland, stoking the
city's dynamism. Memduh Karakullukcu, 35, schooled at MIT, Columbia
and the London School of Economics, worked as an investment banker
and consultant in Europe and the United States before returning to
head Istanbul Technical University's prestigious technology
incubator. "For the first time, living in Istanbul doesn't mean that
I'm left out of the major social and financial networks," he says.
"I can be part of all that from here." These new repatriates bring a
worldliness and an openness their parents' generation lacks.
"There's a cultural shift. Both Turks and foreigners are excited
about the possibilities of the city, which has been a well-kept
secret for so long," says Oya Eczacibasi, chairwoman of the
Istanbul Modern.
Europe may yet balk
at admitting Turkey to its Union. Yet the world won't end if it
does. All signs suggest that Istanbul will continue to re-create
itself, perhaps even more energetically. Remember the sounds of
Istanbul's streets—European and Turkish and Balkan and Middle
Eastern, all coming together in a strange but beautiful harmony.
|